The state water board held its first hearing Thursday since Gov. Jerry Brown’s plan to move more water efficiently from Northern California to the south was pared down.
After losing financial support from some Central Valley farmers and backers in Silicon Valley last fall, the state Department of Water Resources announced Wednesday it would build one concrete tunnel under the Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta first and construct the second tunnel only if more money becomes available.
The tunnels would be 35 miles long and 40 feet high, stretching from new intakes 15 miles north of Sacramento, skirting the environmentally sensitive delta where water is supplied by court order to ensure the survival of native salmon and the Delta smelt.
The 2010 two-tunnel plan called the California WaterFix would be paid for by water districts according to how much water they take from the improved State Water Project. A single-tunnel waterway would be similar to the Peripheral Canal defeated by voters in 1982.
During hearings last fall, three Los Angeles city representatives to the Metropolitan Water District of Southern California voted against the project, saying it was too big and would place too great a burden on ratepayers. Metropolitan’s board voted “yes,” approving a $4.3 billion share.
Under either plan, MWD rates would have to increase, which would amount to an increase of $2 to $3 a month in residential water bills, MWD said last fall. The full project would take 17 to 20 years to build.
But after the Westlands Water District in Fresno dropped out, followed by Santa Clara Valley Water District in San Jose, the project was in jeopardy, prompting Brown to pivot to a phased project to keep it alive.
The single-tunnel stage would cost about $10.7 billion, $5.6 billion less than the $16.3 billion cost for the entire project. The state, MWD and other water districts in Southern California may have reluctantly agreed to the staged approach after it became clear the money wasn’t there.
“This is something we expected,” Jeff Kightlinger, general manager of MWD, a provider of water to 19 million Southern Californians and the biggest supporter of WaterFix, said during an interview Thursday. “But I still think for the greater good, a two-tunnel project would be better.”
A singular tunnel reduces the amount of water by one-third, from 9,000 cubic feet per second — equal to 4 million gallons per minute — to 6,000 cfs. However, since the single tunnel does not include the Central Valley Project, a federal aqueduct used exclusively for California farmers, urban districts would gain more shares.
Kightlinger estimated MWD’s portion would rise from 30 percent to about 50 percent. But with fewer water agencies and cities paying, MWD may have to pony up more money.
“There may be some shift in the numbers,” said Kightlinger, though he would not say how much more MWD would pay. “If there is an increase, it would be because we’d be getting greater benefits.”
While the state may be divided over the project, the large water districts from Southern California say the nearly 60-year-old system of levees and canals that sends water 700 miles into drought-stricken Southern California needs an overhaul.
“This is the path forward. It is an investment in the future for the state,” said Jennifer Pierre, general manager of a trade group representing 27 state water contractors. “We don’t want to wait. We are ready to go.”
The Department of Water Resources will produce a supplemental environmental review by June, and Kitghtlinger hopes permits for the first phase will be issued by December, when construction can start.
Representatives of Restore The Delta, an environmental group defending the estuary’s wildlife and the water source for residents, called the hearing a sham, saying the public wasn’t able to comment on the plan because the details are uncertain and the new environmental analysis is incomplete.
“They are trying to force a project to work that cannot,” said Barbara Barrigan-Parrilla, executive director of the group and opponent of the tunnel plan. “They can’t get the science and the money in line with reality.”
She said the tunnel plan does not address California’s warmer winters and dwindling snowmelt, both a result of climate change.
“Fifty-two percent of the time you can’t operate the tunnel, because it is too dry,” she said.
Source: Oc Register
After resistance from local water districts to Jerry Brown’s two-tunnel Delta project, plan could be pared down to just one
More from breaking newsMore posts in breaking news »
- Man charged with hiding explosive in suitcase at Pa. airport; Allegiant flight was bound for Florida
- Congress approves $900B COVID-19 relief bill, sending to Trump
- Trump says Barr resigning, will leave before Christmas
- US allows emergency COVID-19 vaccine in bid to end pandemic
- Judge throws out Trump bid to stop PA vote certification
More from droughtMore posts in drought »
- Will rains bring another Southern California superbloom? Wildflower forecast is murky
- Ocean water from San Diego could stabilize south OC supply, boost desal
- After ‘miracle’ water year, can agencies capture more from next El Niño?
- Making water conservation a ‘California way of life’: Controversial state rules could cost $13 billion
- A fight over precious groundwater in a rural California town is rooted in carrots
More from EnvironmentMore posts in Environment »
- Why e-bikes will be allowed on new multi-use trail in California’s Tahoe National Forest
- Good news for gray whales: “Unusual Mortality Event” declared over
- Southern California researchers part of team that discovered new fish species
- San Clemente’s delayed sand project set to resume end of April
- After protests, SoCalGas scales back plans to test hydrogen energy at UC Irvine
More from Foothill CitiesMore posts in Foothill Cities »
- How to watch, drive, park or take public transit to the LA Marathon on Sunday
- LA Marathon: Experienced runners advise first-timers, who make up 40% of field
- LA County supervisors want Congress to fix broken suicide and crisis hotline
- Rose Parade 2024: Churches near parade route offer cheap parking, tickets and ‘more fun’
- Local officials, nonprofits toss virtual questions at Biden coming to LA on Friday
More from Harbor AreaMore posts in Harbor Area »
- How to watch, drive, park or take public transit to the LA Marathon on Sunday
- LA Marathon: Experienced runners advise first-timers, who make up 40% of field
- LA County supervisors want Congress to fix broken suicide and crisis hotline
- Rose Parade 2024: Churches near parade route offer cheap parking, tickets and ‘more fun’
- Local officials, nonprofits toss virtual questions at Biden coming to LA on Friday
More from High DesertMore posts in High Desert »
- How to watch, drive, park or take public transit to the LA Marathon on Sunday
- LA Marathon: Experienced runners advise first-timers, who make up 40% of field
- LA County supervisors want Congress to fix broken suicide and crisis hotline
- Rose Parade 2024: Churches near parade route offer cheap parking, tickets and ‘more fun’
- Local officials, nonprofits toss virtual questions at Biden coming to LA on Friday
More from Inland EmpireMore posts in Inland Empire »
- How to watch, drive, park or take public transit to the LA Marathon on Sunday
- LA Marathon: Experienced runners advise first-timers, who make up 40% of field
- LA County supervisors want Congress to fix broken suicide and crisis hotline
- Rose Parade 2024: Churches near parade route offer cheap parking, tickets and ‘more fun’
- Local officials, nonprofits toss virtual questions at Biden coming to LA on Friday
More from NewsMore posts in News »
- Storm system delivers thunderstorms, hail in Southern California
- ‘Access Hollywood’ tape won’t be played at Donald Trump’s hush-money criminal trial, judge rules
- Chief justice denies ex-Trump aide, UC Irvine professor Peter Navarro’s bid to delay sentence
- Nature, trails and…tech? How AllTrails CEO aims to make the outdoors more accessible than ever
- Trump’s lawyers say it is impossible for him to post bond covering $454 million civil fraud judgment
More from North BeachesMore posts in North Beaches »
- How to watch, drive, park or take public transit to the LA Marathon on Sunday
- LA Marathon: Experienced runners advise first-timers, who make up 40% of field
- LA County supervisors want Congress to fix broken suicide and crisis hotline
- Rose Parade 2024: Churches near parade route offer cheap parking, tickets and ‘more fun’
- Local officials, nonprofits toss virtual questions at Biden coming to LA on Friday
More from NorthwestMore posts in Northwest »
- How to watch, drive, park or take public transit to the LA Marathon on Sunday
- LA Marathon: Experienced runners advise first-timers, who make up 40% of field
- LA County supervisors want Congress to fix broken suicide and crisis hotline
- Rose Parade 2024: Churches near parade route offer cheap parking, tickets and ‘more fun’
- Local officials, nonprofits toss virtual questions at Biden coming to LA on Friday
More from OC beachesMore posts in OC beaches »
- How to watch, drive, park or take public transit to the LA Marathon on Sunday
- LA Marathon: Experienced runners advise first-timers, who make up 40% of field
- LA County supervisors want Congress to fix broken suicide and crisis hotline
- Rose Parade 2024: Churches near parade route offer cheap parking, tickets and ‘more fun’
- Local officials, nonprofits toss virtual questions at Biden coming to LA on Friday
More from Orange County NewsMore posts in Orange County News »
More from Palos Verdes PeninsulaMore posts in Palos Verdes Peninsula »
- How to watch, drive, park or take public transit to the LA Marathon on Sunday
- LA Marathon: Experienced runners advise first-timers, who make up 40% of field
- Palos Verdes Peninsula coast may have low-level radioactive materials, new study says
- LA County supervisors want Congress to fix broken suicide and crisis hotline
- Rose Parade 2024: Churches near parade route offer cheap parking, tickets and ‘more fun’
More from San Fernando ValleyMore posts in San Fernando Valley »
- How to watch, drive, park or take public transit to the LA Marathon on Sunday
- For this Palmdale father, riding a handcycle in LA Marathon is ‘wildest dream’
- LA Marathon: Experienced runners advise first-timers, who make up 40% of field
- Second anniversary of Ukraine invasion: Holy Virgin Mary Russian Orthodox church welcomes all
- State orders shutdown of LA County’s two largest juvenile facilities
More from San Gabriel ValleyMore posts in San Gabriel Valley »
- How to watch, drive, park or take public transit to the LA Marathon on Sunday
- LA Marathon: Experienced runners advise first-timers, who make up 40% of field
- State orders shutdown of LA County’s two largest juvenile facilities
- Months after 10 Freeway fire, danger still lurks beneath transit routes, inspections reveal
- Who were the Monterey Park shooting victims? A year later, a reflection
More from South BayMore posts in South Bay »
- How to watch, drive, park or take public transit to the LA Marathon on Sunday
- LA Marathon: Experienced runners advise first-timers, who make up 40% of field
- State orders shutdown of LA County’s two largest juvenile facilities
- Months after 10 Freeway fire, danger still lurks beneath transit routes, inspections reveal
- LA County supervisors want Congress to fix broken suicide and crisis hotline
More from South BeachesMore posts in South Beaches »
- How to watch, drive, park or take public transit to the LA Marathon on Sunday
- LA Marathon: Experienced runners advise first-timers, who make up 40% of field
- Former OC assemblymember hit with $100K fine from state political watchdog
- Biden official hears from packed audience on expanding San Gabriel Mountains monument
- Calling 988 to talk to someone about suicide? The connection could be way off
More from Top Stories BreezeMore posts in Top Stories Breeze »
- Storm system delivers thunderstorms, hail in Southern California
- EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decades after a partial ban
- LAX travelers fight ‘absolutely horrendous traffic’ mess on Sunday
- LA Marathon: 3,500 young runners from Students Run LA raced, and all won
- Realtors settlement brings confusion, relief to Southern California’s real estate industry
More from top stories ivdbMore posts in top stories ivdb »
- Storm system delivers thunderstorms, hail in Southern California
- EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decades after a partial ban
- LAX travelers fight ‘absolutely horrendous traffic’ mess on Sunday
- Realtors settlement brings confusion, relief to Southern California’s real estate industry
- Why Mt. Baldy can be deceptive, deadly for novice and skilled hikers alike
More from Top Stories LADNMore posts in Top Stories LADN »
- Storm system delivers thunderstorms, hail in Southern California
- EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decades after a partial ban
- From ‘legacy runners’ to Kenyan fans, voices from the 2024 LA Marathon
- LAX travelers fight ‘absolutely horrendous traffic’ mess on Sunday
- LA Marathon: 3,500 young runners from Students Run LA raced, and all won
More from Top Stories LBPTMore posts in Top Stories LBPT »
- Storm system delivers thunderstorms, hail in Southern California
- EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decades after a partial ban
- LAX travelers fight ‘absolutely horrendous traffic’ mess on Sunday
- LA Marathon: 3,500 young runners from Students Run LA raced, and all won
- Realtors settlement brings confusion, relief to Southern California’s real estate industry
More from Top Stories OCRMore posts in Top Stories OCR »
- Storm system delivers thunderstorms, hail in Southern California
- Chief justice denies ex-Trump aide, UC Irvine professor Peter Navarro’s bid to delay sentence
- EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decades after a partial ban
- 34 home burglaries committed in Irvine in last 35 days, police say
- LAX travelers fight ‘absolutely horrendous traffic’ mess on Sunday
More from Top Stories PEMore posts in Top Stories PE »
- Storm system delivers thunderstorms, hail in Southern California
- EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decades after a partial ban
- Realtors settlement brings confusion, relief to Southern California’s real estate industry
- Why Mt. Baldy can be deceptive, deadly for novice and skilled hikers alike
- Southern California unemployment hits 5.3%, highest in 2 years
More from Top Stories PSNMore posts in Top Stories PSN »
- Storm system delivers thunderstorms, hail in Southern California
- EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decades after a partial ban
- LAX travelers fight ‘absolutely horrendous traffic’ mess on Sunday
- LA Marathon: 3,500 young runners from Students Run LA raced, and all won
- Realtors settlement brings confusion, relief to Southern California’s real estate industry
More from top stories rdfMore posts in top stories rdf »
- Storm system delivers thunderstorms, hail in Southern California
- EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decades after a partial ban
- Realtors settlement brings confusion, relief to Southern California’s real estate industry
- Why Mt. Baldy can be deceptive, deadly for novice and skilled hikers alike
- Southern California unemployment hits 5.3%, highest in 2 years
More from Top Stories SGVTMore posts in Top Stories SGVT »
- Storm system delivers thunderstorms, hail in Southern California
- EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decades after a partial ban
- LAX travelers fight ‘absolutely horrendous traffic’ mess on Sunday
- LA Marathon: 3,500 young runners from Students Run LA raced, and all won
- Realtors settlement brings confusion, relief to Southern California’s real estate industry
More from top stories sunMore posts in top stories sun »
- Storm system delivers thunderstorms, hail in Southern California
- EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decades after a partial ban
- Realtors settlement brings confusion, relief to Southern California’s real estate industry
- Why Mt. Baldy can be deceptive, deadly for novice and skilled hikers alike
- Southern California unemployment hits 5.3%, highest in 2 years
More from Top Stories WDNMore posts in Top Stories WDN »
- Storm system delivers thunderstorms, hail in Southern California
- EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decades after a partial ban
- LAX travelers fight ‘absolutely horrendous traffic’ mess on Sunday
- LA Marathon: 3,500 young runners from Students Run LA raced, and all won
- Realtors settlement brings confusion, relief to Southern California’s real estate industry
Be First to Comment