There was no set deadline, but the perception of one seemed real enough.
It was a Saturday in early August and Jose Lopez’s downtown Los Angeles apartment looked like a command center of sorts. With a printer set up on the center of the kitchen table, a dozen young immigrants sat with computers in the kitchen and living room, typing with quiet intensity.
Their goal: To get their DACA renewal applications into the government, via Fed Ex, that night. They wanted to file the paperwork before a district court judge ruled on a lawsuit that challenges Deferred Action for Childhood Arrival — the program created by president Barack Obama that grants young immigrants a work visa and temporary deferral from deportation.
“It was as quiet as it could be,” Lopez said of the DACA application-a-thon. “Everybody was typing, unless someone had a question.
“You could feel the tension in the room.”
It turned out the deadline wasn’t real; the Texas judge held off on his ruling, which is expected any day now.
But the fear palpable in Lopez’s apartment that night remains. For DACA recipients — a world that includes about 89,000 people in Southern California — there is growing anxiety about a cluster of lawsuits moving through the courts that could determine the fate of the program and, with it, their futures.
Many are particularly concerned about the ruling expected as soon as this week from District Judge Andrew Hanen in Texas.
In 2015, Hanen blocked Obama’s plan to expand DACA and create a similar program for parents of American-born children, a program called DAPA, or Deferred Action for Parents of Americans and Lawful Permanent Residents. That case reached the U.S. Supreme Court, which split 4-4, so the expanded protections never went into effect.
Dianey Murillo, an organizer for the Inland Empire-Immigrant Youth Collective, works at her desk at the organization’s headquarters in Ontario, Calif. on Tuesday, Oct. 10, 2017. (Photo by Rachel Luna, The Press-Enterprise/SCNG)
“The case that is triggering anxiety is the one in Texas,” said Dianey Murillo, an organizer with the Inland Empire Immigrant Youth Collective.
While many expect Hanen to rule against DACA, attorney Thomas Saenz argues that there are important differences between Obama’s expanded plan and the existing version of the DACA program. The program to protect parents, DAPA, was never implemented. DACA, on the other hand, has existed for six years and has been used by some 800,000 young immigrants nationally without causing irreparable injury to the states, said Saenz, president and general counsel of the Mexican American Legal Defense Counsel, or MALDEF.
Even if Hanen rules against DACA, the Texas judge “has no greater authority than any other district judge in the country,” Saenz said.
And so far, other courts have ruled favorably toward DACA.
If Hanen does rule against DACA, contravening the orders of other courts across the country, the federal government “would face a conundrum,” in Saenz’ view, because it “does not have the right to choose which injunction it likes best.”
Most observers believe the case will likely be settled before the U.S. Supreme Court, unless Congress comes up with a different plan for unauthorized youth, often known as “Dreamers.”
The Texas lawsuit is an outlier among the lawsuits, some of which have been consolidated or are moving in tandem through five federal courts: in California, New York, Maryland, Washington D.C. and Texas. Most seek to protect DACA, not dismantle it.
A pro-immigration activist holds a sign in front of the U.S. Supreme Court in 2016, which split 4-4 on the fate of the DACA program. Most experts believe the Supreme Court eventually will again hear arguments related to the program. (Photo by Alex Wong/Getty Images)
Lawsuits were filed after Attorney General Jeff Sessions announced on Sept. 5 an end to the DACA program, which some argue is unconstitutional, an abusive overreach of executive powers by President Obama, and a financial burden on states.
The lawsuits include one collectively known as Regents of the University of California v. Department of Homeland Security. On Jan. 9, District Judge William Alsup ruled in favor of UC, issuing a preliminary injunction that allowed existing DACA holders to renew their status.
Other courts in New York and Washington D.C. also ruled in favor of DACA. Most recently, on Aug. 3, District Court Judge John Bates in D.C. called the cancellation of DACA “arbitrary and capricious” and he ordered full restoration of the program, allowing also for new applicants to file, but he delayed implementation for 20 days.
Attorney General Sessions earlier this month criticized decisions “in which courts have improperly used judicial power to steer, enjoin, modify, and direct executive policy.”
Meanwhile, a district judge in Maryland struck down a challenge to the program, although he opined: “This court does not like the outcome of this case, but is constrained by its constitutionally limited role.”
With Hanen’s ruling pending, as well as various appeals across the country, this is considered a critical time for the nearly 700,000 people who currently hold DACA and the hundreds of thousands of others who may qualify for the temporary protection.
“In the next few weeks and few months, we could see developments in these cases that significantly alter the landscape for DACA recipients,” said Marielena Hincapié, executive director of the National Immigration Law Center.
There are fewer than 700,000 people currently holding DACA status. That’s a drop from the approximate 800,000 original applicants.
About 40,000 DACA recipients dropped from the pool because they became permanent legal residents, according to a U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services spokeswoman. Others who didn’t renew may have missed a window to apply after the program was suspended or may not have been able to afford the $495 renewal fee.
“Many didn’t renew out of fear or because they didn’t have the funds,” said Sheridan Aguirre, a spokesman for the United We Dream group, which bills itself as the largest immigrant youth-led network in the country.
California has the most people protected by DACA; nearly 197,000 as of last January, according to the Migration Policy Institute.
Most polls show that a majority of Americans support DACA. And for those who are accepted into the program, it’s a game changer. They can work, travel, drive, and basically live without the fear of being detained for deportation.
A new survey released Wednesday by the Immigration Policy at American Progress, a progressive public policy research and advocacy organization, describes the impact of the program on its recipients. Of 1,050 people interviewed, 54 percent moved to a job with better pay and nearly half got jobs with better working conditions as a result of their DACA protections, benefits that better fit their education and goals.
Jose Lopez, a DACA recipient and Dream Team LA organizer. Like other DACA activists, he’s urging everyone with the status to renew their applications early. (Photo by David Crane, Daily News/SCNG)
Lopez, the Dream Team LA organizer, said he would fit in that category.
“DACA has done a lot of things for me. I have a stable job. I have a new car. I built up credit and I’m looking to buy a house,” Lopez said. “Every time I renew, I’m asked about my assets and income on the application. And every year, it increases. And it’s all due to DACA.”
Immigrant advocates are urging DACA applicants to renew their applications now, regardless of when they expire.
Aguirre, of the United We Dream group, said he sent off for his own renewal in the last week, a year early. Murillo, from the Inland Empire group, also sent hers in early.
As did Lopez and his friends, who rushed to file their renewals on that recent Saturday, when sprawled across Lopez’s home “you could hear printers all day.”
“Everyone was doing their applications,” Lopez said, “without knowing what the future of DACA holds.”
MORE STORIES ABOUT DACA PROGRAM:
What happens if Trump ends DACA?
At least for now, DACA recipients can reapply for deportation relief
DACA debate: Don’t call them ‘Dreamers,’ or pawns
March 5 was supposed to be the beginning of the end of DACA: What now?
Here’s where DACA’s Dreamers come from, where they live, and what their economic impact is
MORE ON IMMIGRATION:
Like others in her boots, immigrant veteran faces battle to become citizen
American from Orange County detained in Vietnam prison; congresswoman threatens ‘consequences’
Rohrabacher tours Irvine immigrant detention facility, refuses to answer questions about Russia
Administration: More than 1,800 children reunited after border split
ICE agents target five 7-Eleven stores in LA area amid nationwide immigration action
Source: OC Register
DACA Texas court ruling expected soon, but future of young undocumented far from clear
More from Crime + Public SafetyMore posts in Crime + Public Safety »
- Triple-digit heat hitting some Southern California communities
- Garden Grove man, who served time for terrorism, now accused of drug trafficking
- Woman charged with murder after pursuit that ended with fatal crash in Dana Point
- Southern California heat to stick around this week, but a cool-off is coming
- 15-year-old fatally stabbed in Aliso Viejo, Mission Viejo woman arrested
More from immigrationMore posts in immigration »
- Chicago’s response to migrant influx stirs longstanding frustrations among Black residents
- Supreme Court halts Texas law allowing police to arrest migrants
- Biden, Trump to make dueling trips to the Mexico border
- House vote to impeach Homeland Security Secretary Mayorkas fails due to GOP defections
- Analysis: What the border bill would and wouldn’t do
More from National NewsMore posts in National News »
- Chicago’s response to migrant influx stirs longstanding frustrations among Black residents
- How 4/20 grew from humble roots to marijuana’s high holiday
- Russian strike on Ukraine city kills at least 17 people
- Virginia becomes first Southern state to abolish child marriage
- Trump trial: Why can’t Americans see or hear what is going on inside the courtroom?
More from national politicsMore posts in national politics »
- Biden is off on details of his uncle’s WWII death as he calls Trump unfit to lead the military
- Virginia becomes first Southern state to abolish child marriage
- Sen. Laphonza Butler isn’t just keeping a seat warm in Washington
- States race to restrict deepfake porn as it becomes easier to create
- Trump trial: Why can’t Americans see or hear what is going on inside the courtroom?
More from NewsMore posts in News »
- Amid valedictorian protest, USC scrubs outside commencement speakers, honorees
- 4 Inland men sentenced to prison for roles in Jan. 6 Capitol riot
- Chicago’s response to migrant influx stirs longstanding frustrations among Black residents
- In reversal, more areas allow high-speed police chases
- How 4/20 grew from humble roots to marijuana’s high holiday
More from OCR NewsletterMore posts in OCR Newsletter »
- Frumpy Mom: How to have a roof over your head
- Southern Californians frustrated with illegal immigration deliver message to Guatemalan Consulate in San Bernardino
- Can California’s public employee unions thwart U.S. Supreme Court’s Janus decision?
- Working but still poor? Earned Income Tax Credit eases, but doesn’t solve, that problem
- Catholic leaders urge Reps. Royce, Walters to back DACA, parishioners to pray for Dreamers
More from politicsMore posts in politics »
- Amid valedictorian protest, USC scrubs outside commencement speakers, honorees
- Chicago’s response to migrant influx stirs longstanding frustrations among Black residents
- Huntington Beach councilmembers pledge to fight state’s lawsuit over city’s voter ID measure
- Biden is off on details of his uncle’s WWII death as he calls Trump unfit to lead the military
- Russian strike on Ukraine city kills at least 17 people
More from Top Stories BreezeMore posts in Top Stories Breeze »
- Amid valedictorian protest, USC scrubs outside commencement speakers, honorees
- Need speed humps, bumps or cushions on your street to slow down drivers?
- Earth Day: A look at what’s being done to decrease plastic use
- California’s fast food prices rose 7% before new $20 wage, No. 1 jump in US
- Sen. Laphonza Butler isn’t just keeping a seat warm in Washington
More from top stories ivdbMore posts in top stories ivdb »
- Amid valedictorian protest, USC scrubs outside commencement speakers, honorees
- Need speed humps, bumps or cushions on your street to slow down drivers?
- Earth Day: A look at what’s being done to decrease plastic use
- California’s fast food prices rose 7% before new $20 wage, No. 1 jump in US
- Death row inmate transfers to Chino prison spur safety concerns with mayor, police
More from Top Stories LADNMore posts in Top Stories LADN »
- Amid valedictorian protest, USC scrubs outside commencement speakers, honorees
- Need speed humps, bumps or cushions on your street to slow down drivers?
- Earth Day: A look at what’s being done to decrease plastic use
- California’s fast food prices rose 7% before new $20 wage, No. 1 jump in US
- Studio City freeway crash that killed LA Fire Department recruit not classified as a hit-and-run
More from Top Stories LBPTMore posts in Top Stories LBPT »
- Amid valedictorian protest, USC scrubs outside commencement speakers, honorees
- Need speed humps, bumps or cushions on your street to slow down drivers?
- These women are creating community at the Grand Prix of Long Beach
- Earth Day: A look at what’s being done to decrease plastic use
- California’s fast food prices rose 7% before new $20 wage, No. 1 jump in US
More from Top Stories OCRMore posts in Top Stories OCR »
- Amid valedictorian protest, USC scrubs outside commencement speakers, honorees
- Need speed humps, bumps or cushions on your street to slow down drivers?
- Man gets 11 years for DUI crash that killed 3 returning from Bible study in Placentia
- Earth Day: A look at what’s being done to decrease plastic use
- Huntington Beach councilmembers pledge to fight state’s lawsuit over city’s voter ID measure
More from Top Stories PEMore posts in Top Stories PE »
- Amid valedictorian protest, USC scrubs outside commencement speakers, honorees
- 4 Inland men sentenced to prison for roles in Jan. 6 Capitol riot
- Need speed humps, bumps or cushions on your street to slow down drivers?
- Earth Day: A look at what’s being done to decrease plastic use
- California’s fast food prices rose 7% before new $20 wage, No. 1 jump in US
More from Top Stories PSNMore posts in Top Stories PSN »
- Amid valedictorian protest, USC scrubs outside commencement speakers, honorees
- Need speed humps, bumps or cushions on your street to slow down drivers?
- Earth Day: A look at what’s being done to decrease plastic use
- California’s fast food prices rose 7% before new $20 wage, No. 1 jump in US
- Sen. Laphonza Butler isn’t just keeping a seat warm in Washington
More from top stories rdfMore posts in top stories rdf »
- Amid valedictorian protest, USC scrubs outside commencement speakers, honorees
- Need speed humps, bumps or cushions on your street to slow down drivers?
- Earth Day: A look at what’s being done to decrease plastic use
- California’s fast food prices rose 7% before new $20 wage, No. 1 jump in US
- Death row inmate transfers to Chino prison spur safety concerns with mayor, police
More from Top Stories SGVTMore posts in Top Stories SGVT »
- Amid valedictorian protest, USC scrubs outside commencement speakers, honorees
- Need speed humps, bumps or cushions on your street to slow down drivers?
- Earth Day: A look at what’s being done to decrease plastic use
- California’s fast food prices rose 7% before new $20 wage, No. 1 jump in US
- Sen. Laphonza Butler isn’t just keeping a seat warm in Washington
More from top stories sunMore posts in top stories sun »
- Amid valedictorian protest, USC scrubs outside commencement speakers, honorees
- Need speed humps, bumps or cushions on your street to slow down drivers?
- Earth Day: A look at what’s being done to decrease plastic use
- California’s fast food prices rose 7% before new $20 wage, No. 1 jump in US
- Death row inmate transfers to Chino prison spur safety concerns with mayor, police
More from Top Stories WDNMore posts in Top Stories WDN »
- Amid valedictorian protest, USC scrubs outside commencement speakers, honorees
- Need speed humps, bumps or cushions on your street to slow down drivers?
- Earth Day: A look at what’s being done to decrease plastic use
- California’s fast food prices rose 7% before new $20 wage, No. 1 jump in US
- Sen. Laphonza Butler isn’t just keeping a seat warm in Washington
Be First to Comment